fi
FI
Finland
en-FI
fi_inst_classes
inst
Institutional
en
en
For use by professional clients and/or equivalent investor types in your jurisdiction (not to be used with or passed on to retail clients).
Silhouette of person walking up escalator in office building

Insights

It’s a value trap! How research intensity can help reveal genuine recovery stocks

Sally Springer
Senior Sustainable Research Analyst, Global Research

Key Takeaways

  • Columbia Threadneedle Investments looks for good companies trading below their intrinsic value. We do this by undertaking fundamental analysis and an assessment of the potential opportunity a firm has to outperform market expectations
  • Often companies trading below their intrinsic value have fallen out of favour with the market due to ‘self-inflicted’ wounds, and with an appropriate change in strategy there is potential for the firms to turn around
  • However, history is littered with examples of companies which have put in place performance improvement plans, only for them to fail and investors to lose out. So, how do we try and avoid this?
  • With intangible asset growth increasingly a driver of performance growth, a core research theme for us is ‘human capital’ – a central component of intangible value
  • Our sustainable research team looks at how firms are managing their workforce and aligning their HR strategy in support of the recovery plan
  • This research intensity, and engagement with senior managers and leaders, allows us to understand how a company’s culture and new strategy are being integrated, giving us an additional perspective

The price isn’t right!

Over the long run, capital markets are perceived to be efficient, reflecting valuation, growth and the cost of capital.1 This means that stocks with higher intrinsic value2 will be priced appropriately. However, in the shorter term company valuations can fluctuate above or below their intrinsic value, driven by news flow, profit surprises and changing externalities such as geopolitical events or new regulation.

Often these short-term share price movements are due to self-inflicted wounds such as an ill-judged acquisition strategy, or poor product, pricing or marketing decisions, leading to a loss of competitive positioning. For many companies, earnings disappointments will continue over a substantive period, leading to further share price decline and the company trading at a significant discount to its intrinsic value.

Value trap or recovery stock?

At Columbia Threadneedle Investments we screen for stocks which have strong financial track records, impressive historic returns and solid balance sheets – and whose share prices have statistically underperformed their long-term average. A fundamental assessment of the potential upside in a company’s valuation (assuming performance recovers) is carried out by the sector analyst. They will consider among other things: whether the firm operates in a sector which has a favourable industry outlook; the level of concentration in that sector, for example, is the industry an oligopoly; whether the firm has significant intangible assets, such as a strong brand; and, critically, its current level of cash generation, which may be required to fund the turnaround or restructuring of the business.

The analyst will also consider trends in quarterly earnings and certain signals3 that may indicate the firm is a potential investment opportunity. One of the most important of these is senior management change at the board level. A new management team enables a fresh perspective of the company’s current and future strategy, unburdened by past decisions.

This level of scrutiny by Columbia Threadneedle’s investment team is to ensure we do not invest in ‘value traps’. This is where investors perceive that a particular stock is undervalued because it has fallen out of favour with the market, but where there is actually a valid reason for the decline in valuation4 – for example, a new technology has made the company’s product redundant, such as the move from physical media to streaming that spelled the end for Blockbuster.

Top down …

Where a company has been identified as a recovery stock, whereby its share price may not reflect its intrinsic value, Columbia Threadneedle will engage with the senior management team to understand and judge whether the initiatives set out in their recovery plan will lead the company back to profitability. In addition, the Columbia Threadneedle Governance team, alongside the portfolio managers and sector analyst, will meet with non-executive directors such as the Chair and the Senior Independent Director to identify whether the Board collectively has enough experience and knowledge to support the executive team to implement a turnaround. This also enables Columbia Threadneedle to judge whether the Board provides enough checks and balances to the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) and Chief Financial Officer (CFO) to ensure they are sufficiently challenged as they execute the new strategy, being prepared to review the process as necessary.

… versus bottom up

However, history is littered with examples of companies who, despite appearing to have a comprehensive strategy to improve performance, fail to resurrect their revenues and earnings. While, as Warren Buffet acknowledges, this can sometimes be due to a ‘mis-evaluation of the company or the industry in which it operates’5, it is often the case that the company’s new strategy has not been appropriately disseminated throughout each managerial layer of the business. Senior leaders and managers not fully on board with the changes required of them and their teams cannot articulate the ‘what’ and ‘why’ to their direct reports, who in turn fail to enact the necessary changes. A study by Towers Watson found that only 25% of change initiatives were successful over the long term6, suggesting that making substantive changes to an organisation without attempting to ensure the business’s values, vision and culture are adapted accordingly is counterproductive.

In order for a company’s new strategy to have the best chance of success, senior management must make distinct efforts to proactively align their internal culture to their new vision. This includes enabling employees at every level of the organisation to understand the plan, what is expected of them, and how it will support and put the company on a stable footing in the longer term.

Putting it into practice

Human capital thematic research

A core research theme for Columbia Threadneedle is ‘human capital’. We prioritise this because the way firms create value has fundamentally shifted over the past 50 years from one based on tangible assets, such as equipment, buildings and inventory, to one based on intangible assets including intellectual assets – such as patents, brands, R&D and customer relationships – all of which are derived from a firm’s human capital (employees). Indeed, management teams often refer to their employees as their ‘greatest asset’7. Therefore, assessing how firms are managing their human capital and aligning their HR strategy to support their business strategy is critical to our investment thesis.

To help us do this we created the “Five ‘S’ framework of human capital management”8 (Figure 1).

Figure 1: the Five ‘S‘ framework of human capital management
Figure 1: the Five S framework of human capital management

Source: Columbia Threadneedle Investments, 2023

The ‘S’ of ‘strategy’ is the levers a firm can pull to manage and align its human resource to its corporate strategy. This includes investing in training to upskill employees so they can adapt to changing technologies, customer expectations or the marketplace, or offering flexible working arrangements to support recruitment and retention.

However, the most fundamental element of a firm’s internal strategy is the culture, vision and values management promote internally. This is particularly true within a company looking to improve performance after a sustained period of underperformance. Employees are being asked to adapt to a shifting internal landscape, which may include job or business line losses. To ensure the successful execution of a turnaround strategy, employees throughout the organisation must understand the reasons for the changes they need to take, otherwise there is a risk that ‘culture will eat (the new) strategy for breakfast’9.

Engagement

To understand how a company’s culture and new strategy are being integrated, Columbia Threadneedle will engage with a company’s senior management team and, importantly, its senior leaders. Because although the Board comes up with the ‘turnaround’ strategy, it’s the senior leaders who are responsible for its implementation. These leaders may be the ones setting the remuneration policy to encourage employees to focus on implementing the key elements of the corporate strategy. Or they may be the ones in control of managing and allocating resources efficiently and effectively between departments so that each business line has the required technology and skillsets to support the new plan.

By meeting these individuals, Columbia Threadneedle can understand how well the new plan is understood throughout the managerial hierarchy. We will ask them to: explain the practical changes they will make within their business units to implement the recovery plan; say how they are communicating and demonstrating to their direct reports why the changes need to be made; find out whether they are adapting their performance assessment and remuneration policies to motivate employees to align their actions with new business priorities; and explore how senior leaders are monitoring progress and making any necessary revisions, and if there is a reporting mechanism back to senior managers of what is and isn’t working well.

Research intensity

Fixing a poor culture or refocusing the vision of the organisation does not ensure the company will make a good investment; however, our engagement does give us an additional research perspective for our assessment of the future financial performance of a company.

At Columbia Threadneedle we believe in research intensity. This is through collaboration between different parts of the firm including sector analysts, governance, portfolio managers and the sustainable research team exchanging
insights, perspectives and ideas. This exchange of views leads to better insights, and better insights – we believe – lead to better performance for our clients.

By undertaking the core fundamental analysis of a potential investment trading below its historical norms and incorporating views from meetings we have with executive management and senior leadership, including perspectives on how the company aligns human capital to its turnaround strategy, we gain greater insight as to whether a company is genuinely a potential investment opportunity or simply a ‘value trap’.

Case study: Unilever10

‘The culture is right’

As a consumer company established in the 20th century but with its roots in the 19th century, Unilever has, by function of its longevity, experienced periods of strength and weakness. However, following a period of extended operational underperformance, driven in part by a failed acquisition strategy and a shift of focus away from its core values, the business hired a new CEO to set out an action plan to improve its strategic focus and growth.

Following a thorough fundamental assessment of the potential upside opportunity of investing in the company if it was able to consistently execute its new ‘action plan’, we initiated engagement. Given Unilever’s poor recent track
record we met with the executive management team, the Chair, and with senior leaders such as the Chief Talent & Reward Officer to understand the depth and breadth of potential change the business was undertaking.

In our meetings we were reassured that a bottom-up approach to implementing fundamental changes had been taken. Stretching goals were incorporated within incentive plans. In addition, incentivisation at every level of the organisation – from employees ‘on the shop floor’ to the executive management team – was changed to improve the line of sight between individual performance and company results. A third-party consultant was hired to initiate a thorough assessment of the skillset needed across the firm’s senior leaders and managers in order to sharpen the business’s current and future performance. This resulted in four out of the five business division leaders being replaced.

Overall, the meeting highlighted that Unilever was aiming to align its human capital strategy to the CEO’s turnaround plan by coordinating its culture and skillset accordingly. These additional insights further indicated that the intrinsic value of the business may indeed be higher than the current share price – and therefore the company could indeed be a potential turnaround investment candidate.

Key topics

Subscribe to insights

Get the most out of your email by tailoring the types of insights and information you would like to receive from us.

Latest articles

With intangible asset growth increasingly a driver of performance growth, a core research theme for us is ‘human capital’. It's just one way our Global Fundamental Research Group feeds into our investment process.
Our fixed income team provide their weekly snapshot of market events.
It’s a sector which we’re positive on, for several reasons ranging from regulation and valuations to fundamentals.
Key topics
Related topics

PDF

It’s a value trap! How research intensity can help reveal genuine recovery stocks

1 Charles H Wang PhD, Short-Term and Long-Term Market Inefficiencies and Their Implications, 5 November 2004
2 The intrinsic value of an asset or security is its inherent value based on an objective calculation using estimates of future cash flow, risk and growth opportunities.
3 Management change, rotation of shareholders including activist shareholder, sell-side recommendation rotation etc.
4 WallStreetPrep, Value Trap, 17 July 2024
5 CNBC make it, Warren Buffett’s failures: 15 investing mistakes he regrets, 15 December 2017
6 Forbes, New Study Explores Why Change Management Fails, 4 September 2013
7 Former Xerox CEO Anne Mulcahy as cited in Forbes, Growing Your Business: Tips For Finding Top Employees, 27 May, 2014
8 Columbia Threadneedle Investments, Thematic Insight: Managing the Human Capital Transition, 2 October 2023
9 Management consultant Peter Drucker as cited by TAB: The Alternative Board, “Culture Eats Strategy For Breakfast” – What Does it Mean?, 26 February 2020
10 Mention of specific stocks is not a recommendation to buy or sell. Past performance does not predict future returns. All intellectual property rights in the brands and logos set out in this article are reserved by respective owners.

Important information:

For use by professional clients and/or equivalent investor types in your jurisdiction (not to be used with or passed on to retail clients). For marketing purposes.

This document is intended for informational purposes only and should not be considered representative of any particular investment. This should not be considered an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any securities or other financial instruments, or to provide investment advice or services. Investing involves risk including the risk of loss of principal. Your capital is at risk. Market risk may affect a single issuer, sector of the economy, industry or the market as a whole. The value of investments is not guaranteed, and therefore an investor may not get back the amount invested. International investing involves certain risks and volatility due to potential political, economic or currency fluctuations and different financial and accounting standards. The securities included herein are for illustrative purposes only, subject to change and should not be construed as a recommendation to buy or sell. Securities discussed may or may not prove profitable. The views expressed are as of the date given, may change as market or other conditions change and may differ from views expressed by other Columbia Threadneedle Investments (Columbia Threadneedle) associates or affiliates. Actual investments or investment decisions made by Columbia Threadneedle and its affiliates, whether for its own account or on behalf of clients, may not necessarily reflect the views expressed. This information is not intended to provide investment advice and does not take into consideration individual investor circumstances. Investment decisions should always be made based on an investor’s specific financial needs, objectives, goals, time horizon and risk tolerance. Asset classes described may not be suitable for all investors. Past performance does not guarantee future results, and no forecast should be considered a guarantee either. Information and opinions provided by third parties have been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but accuracy and completeness cannot be guaranteed. This document and its contents have not been reviewed by any regulatory authority.

In Australia: Issued by Threadneedle Investments Singapore (Pte.) Limited [“TIS”], ARBN 600 027 414. TIS is exempt from the requirement to hold an Australian financial services licence under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and relies on Class Order 03/1102 in respect of the financial services it provides to wholesale clients in Australia. This document should only be distributed in Australia to “wholesale clients” as defined in Section 761G of the Corporations Act. TIS is regulated in Singapore (Registration number: 201101559W) by the Monetary Authority of Singapore under the Securities and Futures Act (Chapter 289), which differ from Australian laws.

In Singapore: Issued by Threadneedle Investments Singapore (Pte.) Limited, 3 Killiney Road, #07-07, Winsland House 1, Singapore 239519, which is regulated in Singapore by the Monetary Authority of Singapore under the Securities and Futures Act (Chapter 289). Registration number: 201101559W. This advertisement has not been reviewed by the Monetary Authority of Singapore.

In Hong Kong: Issued by Threadneedle Portfolio Services Hong Kong Limited 天利投資管理香港有限公司. Unit 3004, Two Exchange Square, 8 Connaught Place, Hong Kong, which is licensed by the Securities and Futures Commission (“SFC”) to conduct Type 1 regulated activities (CE:AQA779). Registered in Hong Kong under the Companies Ordinance (Chapter 622), No. 1173058.

In Japan: Issued by Columbia Threadneedle Investments Japan Co., Ltd. Financial Instruments Business Operator, The Director-General of Kanto Local Finance Bureau (FIBO) No.3281, and a member of Japan Investment Advisers Association and Type II Financial Instruments Firms Association.

In the UK: Issued by Threadneedle Asset Management Limited, No. 573204 and/or Columbia Threadneedle Management Limited, No. 517895, both registered in England and Wales and authorised and regulated in the UK by the Financial Conduct Authority.

In the EEA: Issued by Threadneedle Management Luxembourg S.A., registered with the Registre de Commerce et des Sociétés (Luxembourg), No. B 110242 and/or Columbia Threadneedle Netherlands B.V., regulated by the Dutch Authority for the Financial Markets (AFM), registered No. 08068841.

In Switzerland: Issued by Threadneedle Portfolio Services AG, Registered address: Claridenstrasse 41, 8002 Zurich, Switzerland.

In the Middle East: This document is distributed by Columbia Threadneedle Investments (ME) Limited, which is regulated by the Dubai Financial Services Authority (DFSA). The information in this document is not intended as financial advice and is only intended for persons with appropriate investment knowledge who meet the regulatory criteria to be classified as a Professional Client or Market Counterparty and no other person should act upon it. This document and its contents and any other information or opinions subsequently supplied or given to you are strictly confidential and for the sole use of those attending the presentation. It may not be reproduced in any form or passed on to any third party without the express written permission of CTIME. By accepting delivery of this presentation, you agree that it is not to be copied or reproduced in whole or in part and that you will not disclose its contents to any other person.

This document may be made available to you by an affiliated company which is part of the Columbia Threadneedle Investments group of companies: Columbia Threadneedle Management Limited in the UK; Columbia Threadneedle Netherlands B.V., regulated by the Dutch Authority for the Financial Markets (AFM), registered No. 08068841.

Columbia Threadneedle Investments is the global brand name of the Columbia and Threadneedle group of companies.

Related Insights

6 December 2024

UK equities: don’t believe the doom mongers

While Labour’s first Budget was a surprise in terms of the scale of the fiscal loosening, there remain grounds for cautious optimism about UK equities.
19 November 2024

Melda Mergen

Global Head of Equities

2025 Equity Outlook: Will lower rates and strong earnings be enough to keep markets up?

Going into 2025, strong company fundamentals and trends in innovation could be outweighed by increased geopolitical risk and policy uncertainty.
11 November 2024

Paul Doyle

Head of Europe ex-UK Equities

European reform must wait as the US continues to advance

The continent is struggling with competitiveness and needs to cut interest rates faster – but even that may not be enough.
11 December 2024

Fixed Income Desk

In Credit - Weekly Snapshot

In Credit Weekly Snapshot – December 2024

Our fixed income team provide their weekly snapshot of market events.
9 December 2024

Rosalie Pinkney

Credit Research Analyst, Fixed Income

European banks: strong fundamentals and pockets of value

It’s a sector which we’re positive on, for several reasons ranging from regulation and valuations to fundamentals.
9 December 2024

Steven Bell

Chief Economist, EMEA

Is the UK heading for recession?

There has been a major decline in optimism about UK economic prospects in recent months.

Important information:

For use by professional clients and/or equivalent investor types in your jurisdiction (not to be used with or passed on to retail clients). For marketing purposes.

This document is intended for informational purposes only and should not be considered representative of any particular investment. This should not be considered an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any securities or other financial instruments, or to provide investment advice or services. Investing involves risk including the risk of loss of principal. Your capital is at risk. Market risk may affect a single issuer, sector of the economy, industry or the market as a whole. The value of investments is not guaranteed, and therefore an investor may not get back the amount invested. International investing involves certain risks and volatility due to potential political, economic or currency fluctuations and different financial and accounting standards. The securities included herein are for illustrative purposes only, subject to change and should not be construed as a recommendation to buy or sell. Securities discussed may or may not prove profitable. The views expressed are as of the date given, may change as market or other conditions change and may differ from views expressed by other Columbia Threadneedle Investments (Columbia Threadneedle) associates or affiliates. Actual investments or investment decisions made by Columbia Threadneedle and its affiliates, whether for its own account or on behalf of clients, may not necessarily reflect the views expressed. This information is not intended to provide investment advice and does not take into consideration individual investor circumstances. Investment decisions should always be made based on an investor’s specific financial needs, objectives, goals, time horizon and risk tolerance. Asset classes described may not be suitable for all investors. Past performance does not guarantee future results, and no forecast should be considered a guarantee either. Information and opinions provided by third parties have been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but accuracy and completeness cannot be guaranteed. This document and its contents have not been reviewed by any regulatory authority.

In Australia: Issued by Threadneedle Investments Singapore (Pte.) Limited [“TIS”], ARBN 600 027 414. TIS is exempt from the requirement to hold an Australian financial services licence under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and relies on Class Order 03/1102 in respect of the financial services it provides to wholesale clients in Australia. This document should only be distributed in Australia to “wholesale clients” as defined in Section 761G of the Corporations Act. TIS is regulated in Singapore (Registration number: 201101559W) by the Monetary Authority of Singapore under the Securities and Futures Act (Chapter 289), which differ from Australian laws.

In Singapore: Issued by Threadneedle Investments Singapore (Pte.) Limited, 3 Killiney Road, #07-07, Winsland House 1, Singapore 239519, which is regulated in Singapore by the Monetary Authority of Singapore under the Securities and Futures Act (Chapter 289). Registration number: 201101559W. This advertisement has not been reviewed by the Monetary Authority of Singapore.

In Hong Kong: Issued by Threadneedle Portfolio Services Hong Kong Limited 天利投資管理香港有限公司. Unit 3004, Two Exchange Square, 8 Connaught Place, Hong Kong, which is licensed by the Securities and Futures Commission (“SFC”) to conduct Type 1 regulated activities (CE:AQA779). Registered in Hong Kong under the Companies Ordinance (Chapter 622), No. 1173058.

In Japan: Issued by Columbia Threadneedle Investments Japan Co., Ltd. Financial Instruments Business Operator, The Director-General of Kanto Local Finance Bureau (FIBO) No.3281, and a member of Japan Investment Advisers Association and Type II Financial Instruments Firms Association.

In the UK: Issued by Threadneedle Asset Management Limited, No. 573204 and/or Columbia Threadneedle Management Limited, No. 517895, both registered in England and Wales and authorised and regulated in the UK by the Financial Conduct Authority.

In the EEA: Issued by Threadneedle Management Luxembourg S.A., registered with the Registre de Commerce et des Sociétés (Luxembourg), No. B 110242 and/or Columbia Threadneedle Netherlands B.V., regulated by the Dutch Authority for the Financial Markets (AFM), registered No. 08068841.

In Switzerland: Issued by Threadneedle Portfolio Services AG, Registered address: Claridenstrasse 41, 8002 Zurich, Switzerland.

In the Middle East: This document is distributed by Columbia Threadneedle Investments (ME) Limited, which is regulated by the Dubai Financial Services Authority (DFSA). The information in this document is not intended as financial advice and is only intended for persons with appropriate investment knowledge who meet the regulatory criteria to be classified as a Professional Client or Market Counterparty and no other person should act upon it. This document and its contents and any other information or opinions subsequently supplied or given to you are strictly confidential and for the sole use of those attending the presentation. It may not be reproduced in any form or passed on to any third party without the express written permission of CTIME. By accepting delivery of this presentation, you agree that it is not to be copied or reproduced in whole or in part and that you will not disclose its contents to any other person.

This document may be made available to you by an affiliated company which is part of the Columbia Threadneedle Investments group of companies: Columbia Threadneedle Management Limited in the UK; Columbia Threadneedle Netherlands B.V., regulated by the Dutch Authority for the Financial Markets (AFM), registered No. 08068841.

Columbia Threadneedle Investments is the global brand name of the Columbia and Threadneedle group of companies.

You may also like

Investment approach

Teamwork defines us and is fundamental to our investment approach, which is structured to facilitate the generation, assessment and implementation of good, strong investment ideas for our portfolios.

Funds and Prices

Columbia Threadneedle Investments has a comprehensive range of investment funds catering for a broad range of objectives.

Our Capabilities

We offer a broad range of actively managed investment strategies and solutions covering global, regional and domestic markets and asset classes.

Thank you. You can now visit your preference centre to choose which insights you would like to receive by email.

To view and control which insights you receive from us by email, please visit your preference centre.

Woman listens to music through headphones
Play Video

CT Property Trust- Fund Manager Update

Sed ut perspiciatis unde omnis iste natus error sit voluptatem accusantium doloremque laudantium